The act of formalizing mathematics is not mechanical: it involves substantial mathematical insight in its own right, and it constitutes the essence of formalized mathematics, which is now recognized as a mathematical discipline on its own. Papers published by the AFM contain mathematical novelty or new insight into the theory or use of proof assistants. Papers describing (manual or AI-assisted) formalizations of known results, without this insight, are not in scope.
We aim to publish papers across a variety of mathematical disciplines and proof assistant ecosystems. Papers should be written for a mathematical audience and evaluated on their relevance to the field of mathematics. Introductions should be accessible and target a general audience.
We expect papers to be accompanied by formal proof artifacts. In the absence of formal proof artifacts, mathematical insight gained through the application of artificial intelligence tools is not considered within the scope of the AFM.
Proof auditing, the act of checking that formal statements correspond correctly to their informal counterparts, is a difficult and inherently human part of reviewing formalized mathematics. We expect authors to make these correspondences clear, highlighting and explaining potential mismatches, and linking informal statements to formal statements as often as is appropriate.
Not every project will excel in all of these criteria, and they are not requirements for a paper to be published in the AFM. Nevertheless we encourage authors and reviewers to take these points into consideration.
We emphasize a focus on the usability of formalization projects: authors are encouraged to explain the interfaces around their definitions, if applicable with examples of how their development can be used, and to provide all their files with adequate documentation.